Carmela's Pizzeria - NEW CARLISLE, OH 45344 (Menu & Order Online)

APPETIZERS

Battered Mushroom

4 Breadsticks served with marinara & garlic butter.

Chicken Tenders

Hand breaded chicken tenders served with dipping sauce.

Deep fried pickle spears

Jalapeno Poppers

6 pretzel sticks served with cheese.

Stuffed with bacon and cheddar

Mac & Cheese Bite

Mozzarella Sticks

Cheese, chicken, or beef quesadilla with mozzarella cheese, cheddar cheese, and our marinated tomatoes.

Texas Cheese Fry

Seasoned french fries topped with jalapeno cheddar nacho cheese, bacon and onions.

Wings - Boneless

Hot, Mild, BBQ, Garlic, Sweet Chili, or Roasted Garlic Parm.

Wings - Traditional

Breaded bone in wings topped with either Hot, Mild, BBQ, Garlic, Sweet Chili, or Roasted Garlic Parm. Naked option available upon request.

Sampler Platter

A mix of mozzarella cheese sticks, jalapeno poppers, potato skins, fried pickles, chicken tenders & deep-fried mushrooms. Served with ranch, honey mustard, marinara, and sour cream.

Cheddar Cheese Sauce

Baked Meatballs

Parm Crusted Fries

Tenders (2 Pieces)

Baked Meatballs with Penne

$1 TRADITIONAL WINGS

SALADS

Anti Pasta Salad

Mixed greens lettuce, pepperoni, ham, bacon, mixed peppers, onions, black & green olives, & banana peppers covered with mozzarella.

Chicken Caesar Salad

Crisp romaine mixed with grated romano, shaved parmesan cheese and garlic croutons. Topped with warm chicken breast & served with Caesar dressing.

Buffalo Chicken Salad

Fresh greens mixed with tomatoes, red onion, bacon, cheddar cheese and topped with grilled chicken mixed in a thick hot sauce. Served with ranch dressing.

Crisp mixed greens topped with ham, turkey, bacon, sliced egg, tomatoes & cheese.

Grilled Chicken Salad

Crisp mix greens, sliced red onion, bacon & diced tomato. Topped with cheddar cheese & grilled chicken.

Fried Chicken Salad

Crisp mix greens, sliced red onion, bacon & diced tomato. Topped with cheddar cheese & fried chicken.

Mediterranean Salad

Mixed greens, dried cranberries, mandarin oranges. Topped with strawberries, blueberries, walnuts & feta cheese. Served with raspberry vinaigrette.

Mixed greens topped with our signature marinated tomato basil & onion mixture, cheddar cheese, croutons and choice of dressing.

Walnut Chicken Salad

Our Mediterranean salad with shredded chicken breast.

Carmelas Garden Salad

Mixed greens, marinated tomato basil & red onion, cheddar cheese & croutons.

ENTREES - PASTA

All pasta served with a warm bread stick.

Penne pasta coated with ricotta cheese & pasta sauce. Topped with melted mozzarella.

Chicken Parm Dinner

Fried chicken topped with cheese & pasta sauce over spaghetti

Spaghetti with Meatballs

Marinated Meatball

Combo 2 Kick'n Chicken

2 pieces of hand breaded chicken tenders, choice of side and a piece of toast.

Combo 4 Baked Penne

Penne pasta coated with ricotta cheese & pasta sauce. Topped with melted mozzarella.

Fish & Chips -1

Fried pollock with fries and Cole slaw

Fish & Chips -2

Fried pollock with fries and Cole slaw

PIZZA STANDARD

Our hand-stretched pizza is made from scratch daily using only the best ingredients.

10 - Cheese Pizza

10 - Topped Pizza

14 - Cheese Pizza

14 - Topped Pizza

18 - Cheese Pizza

18 - Topped Pizza

Raw Gluten Free

SPECIALTY PIZZA

Our hand-stretched pizza is made from scratch daily using only the best ingredients.

Buffalo Chicken (10")

Hot sauce, diced chicken breast, peppers & onions, topped with cool ranch dressing.

Chicken Bacon Ranch (10")

Ranch dressing, mixed peppers, diced onions, bacon & diced chicken breast.

Pepperoni, sausage, ham, mixed peppers, green olives, black olives, onions, banana pepper & mushrooms.

Diced ham, pineapple chunks & double cheese.

Meat Lovers (10")

Pepperoni, ham, sausage, & bacon with extra cheese.

Park Layne Special (10")

Pepperoni, mushrooms, mixed peppers, onions, black & green olives, bacon & topped with extra cheese.

Veggie Delight (10")

Mixed peppers, onions, marinated tomatoes, green & black olives, banana peppers & mushrooms.

Buffalo Chicken (14")

Hot sauce, diced chicken breast, peppers & onions, topped with cool ranch dressing.

Chicken Bacon Ranch (14")

Ranch dressing, mixed peppers, diced onions, bacon & diced chicken breast.

Pepperoni, sausage, ham, mixed peppers, green olives, black olives, onions, banana pepper & mushrooms.

Diced ham, pineapple chunks & double cheese.

Meat Lovers (14")

Pepperoni, ham, sausage, & bacon with extra cheese.

Park Layne Special (14")

Pepperoni, mushrooms, mixed peppers, onions, black & green olives, bacon & topped with extra cheese.

Veggie Delight (14")

Mixed peppers, onions, marinated tomatoes, green & black olives, banana peppers & mushrooms.

Buffalo Chicken (18")

Hot sauce, diced chicken breast, peppers & onions, topped with cool ranch dressing.

Chicken Bacon Ranch (18")

Ranch dressing, mixed peppers, diced onions, bacon & diced chicken breast.

Pepperoni, sausage, ham, mixed peppers, green olives, black olives, onions, banana pepper & mushrooms.

Diced ham, pineapple chunks & double cheese.

Meat Lovers (18")

Pepperoni, ham, sausage, & bacon with extra cheese.

Park Layne Special (18")

Pepperoni, mushrooms, mixed peppers, onions, black & green olives, bacon & topped with extra cheese.

Veggie Delight (18")

Mixed peppers, onions, marinated tomatoes, green & black olives, banana peppers & mushrooms.

GLUTEN FREE -14

COMBO MEALS

Combo 2 Kick'n Chicken

2 pieces of hand breaded chicken tenders, choice of side and a piece of toast.

Combo 4 Baked Penne

Penne pasta coated with ricotta cheese & pasta sauce. Topped with melted mozzarella.

Combo 5 1/2 Sub

Combo Side Salad

SANDWICH

Quarter pound burgers served with lettuce, sliced pickles, red onion and sliced tomato on a brioche roll. All burgers accompanied with French fries, onion petals. All sandwiches are served with French fries.

Jalapeno Burger

Mushroom Burger

Served with lettuce, sliced tomato & mayo on harvest baked roll.

Generous amounts of sliced bacon, lettuce & sliced tomato. Served with mayo on grilled bread.

Grilled Cheese, Tomato, & Bacon

Melted American and provolone cheese served with sliced tomato & bacon served between grilled bread.

Fried Chicken Sandwich

Fried Chicken Club

Breaded chicken breast with lettuce, sliced tomato & bacon served with mayo on a brioche roll.

Ham & Cheese Melt

Sliced ham, tomato & bacon with melted provolone cheese. Served with mayo on grilled bread.

Pork Tenderloin

Served with lettuce, tomato, onion & pickle on a brioche bun.

Thinly sliced corned beef, sauerkraut, provolone cheese served with 1000 island dressing between grilled bread.

Sliced turkey, tomato & bacon with melted provolone cheese. Served with mayo on grilled bread.

Roast Beef Melt

SUBS

BBQ Chicken Sub

Buffalo Chicken Sub

Buffalo sauce, diced chicken, peppers, onions with ranch dressing and provolone cheese.

Cheese Steak Sub

Steak patty, pizza sauce, banana peppers & provolone cheese.

Chicken Bacon Ranch Sub

Chicken, peppers, onions, bacon, ranch & provolone.

Salami, ham, pepperoni, banana peppers, provolone cheese. Choice of pizza sauce or Italian dressing.

Pork & beef meatballs covered with sweet marinara, banana peppers & melted mozzarella.

Meat Lovers Sub

Pepperoni, sausage, ham, bacon, banana peppers, provolone & pizza sauce.

Mushroom Steak Sub

Steak patty, topped with mushrooms, provolone & mushroom gravy.

Philly Steak Sub

Rib-eye steak, mayo, roasted peppers & onions, provolone & cheddar cheese.

Pepperoni, sausage, ham, bacon, peppers, onions, black & green olives, banana peppers, pizza sauce & provolone.

Turkey breast, lettuce, tomato, provolone cheese.

Combo 5 1/2 Sub

SIDES

Side Mac N Cheese

Mac & Cheese Order

Cheddar Cheese Sauce

Marinated Meatball

Mixed greens topped with our signature marinated tomato basil & onion mixture, cheddar cheese, croutons and choice of dressing.

Extra Sauce/dressing

Bread Stick (1)

BEVERAGE

DESSERTS

DINE IN SPECIALS

$1 TRADITIONAL WINGS

SUN $3.00 OFF 18"

SUNDAT FOOTBALL SPECIAL

Your cart is empty.